Oil minister sidelines ONGC on Vedanta deal

TNN, Feb 5, 2011, 05.43am IST
NEW DELHI: The oil ministry has not called flagship explorer ONGC for a meeting it will have with top executives of Scottish explorer Cairn Energy Plc and NRI metals tycoon Anil Agarwal's London-listed Vedanta Resources on their near-$10 billion M&A deal, the largest in the Indian oil sector.
The ministry has called the meeting on Sunday to discuss issues blocking Vedanta Resources' bid to acquire control of Cairn India, Cairn Energy's Indian arm, that operates the Barmer oilfield and other acreages in partnership with ONGC.
Industry watchers saw the ministry's move as an indication of its unhappiness with ONGC's unequivocal demand for an equitable royalty regime for the Barmer fields, Cairn's crown jewel, in return for giving up pre-emption rights. ONGC has 30% equity in Barmer but pays 100% royalty owing to a policy anomaly. This has made Barmer a losing proposition for the state-run firm.
But senior ONGC executives say they are trying to protect ONGC's interest by seeking an equitable business relationship with Cairn's future owner. Last week, the ONGC board, which also has a senior bureaucrat representing the ministry, passed a resolution urging that the government should not clear the Cairn-Vedanta deal till an amicable settlement was reached on the issue.
ONGC has stake in most of the 10 acreages held by Cairn India. Its decisions are guided by the principles of oversight by several government agencies such as CAG, CVC and CBI or parliamentary panels. Any complaint of compromising the company's interest could mean trouble for executives taking decisions.
The Prime Minster's Office had set a January-end deadline for the ministry to take a decision. But oil minister S Jaipal Reddy said after taking over the reins from Murli Deora that the ministry will go by the "rule book''. He is also on record admitting that the PMO deadline will be missed since several issues have to be examined by the law ministry. Cairn has differed with ONGC on the issue of pre-emption rights. It says it does not need clearance from ONGC but only "consent". Vedanata too has declined to accept any riders in the government's clearance.
NEW DELHI: The oil ministry has not called flagship explorer ONGC for a meeting it will have with top executives of Scottish explorer Cairn Energy Plc and NRI metals tycoon Anil Agarwal's London-listed Vedanta Resources on their near-$10 billion M&A deal, the largest in the Indian oil sector.
The ministry has called the meeting on Sunday to discuss issues blocking Vedanta Resources' bid to acquire control of Cairn India, Cairn Energy's Indian arm, that operates the Barmer oilfield and other acreages in partnership with ONGC.
Industry watchers saw the ministry's move as an indication of its unhappiness with ONGC's unequivocal demand for an equitable royalty regime for the Barmer fields, Cairn's crown jewel, in return for giving up pre-emption rights. ONGC has 30% equity in Barmer but pays 100% royalty owing to a policy anomaly. This has made Barmer a losing proposition for the state-run firm.
But senior ONGC executives say they are trying to protect ONGC's interest by seeking an equitable business relationship with Cairn's future owner. Last week, the ONGC board, which also has a senior bureaucrat representing the ministry, passed a resolution urging that the government should not clear the Cairn-Vedanta deal till an amicable settlement was reached on the issue.
ONGC has stake in most of the 10 acreages held by Cairn India. Its decisions are guided by the principles of oversight by several government agencies such as CAG, CVC and CBI or parliamentary panels. Any complaint of compromising the company's interest could mean trouble for executives taking decisions.
The Prime Minster's Office had set a January-end deadline for the ministry to take a decision. But oil minister S Jaipal Reddy said after taking over the reins from Murli Deora that the ministry will go by the "rule book''. He is also on record admitting that the PMO deadline will be missed since several issues have to be examined by the law ministry. Cairn has differed with ONGC on the issue of pre-emption rights. It says it does not need clearance from ONGC but only "consent". Vedanata too has declined to accept any riders in the government's clearance.